There is increasing evidence that cocaine addiction is associated with alterations of glutamate homeostasis within the corticostriatal circuitry (
1The glutamate homeostasis hypothesis of addiction.
), the normalization of which by the cysteine prodrug
N-acetylcysteine (NAC), a substrate for the cysteine/glutamate antiporter, has been suggested to decrease cocaine seeking and promote abstinence in preclinical and clinical studies (
2- Brown R.M.
- Kupchik Y.M.
- Kalivas P.W.
The story of glutamate in drug addiction and of N-acetylcysteine as a potential pharmacotherapy.
,
3- Baker D.
- McFarland K.
- Lake R.
- Shen H.
- Toda S.
- Kalivas P.
N-acetyl cysteine-induced blockade of cocaine-induced reinstatement.
,
4- LaRowe S.
- Kalivas P.
- Nicholas J.
- Randall P.
- Mardikian P.
- Malcolm R.
A double-blind placebo-controlled trial of N-acetylcysteine in the treatment of cocaine dependence.
,
5Murray J, Lacoste J, Belin D. (2012): N-Acetylcysteine as a treatment for addiction. In: Belin D, editor. Addictions: From Pathophysiology to Treatment. Rijeka, Croatia: InTech, 335–380.
,
6- Murray J.
- Everitt B.
- Belin D.
N-Acetylcysteine reduces early- and late-stage cocaine seeking without affecting cocaine taking in rats.
). However, the psychological and neurobiological mechanisms whereby NAC facilitates abstinence are not fully understood. Indeed, in a double-blind placebo-controlled trial (
4- LaRowe S.
- Kalivas P.
- Nicholas J.
- Randall P.
- Mardikian P.
- Malcolm R.
A double-blind placebo-controlled trial of N-acetylcysteine in the treatment of cocaine dependence.
), NAC treatment resulted neither in abstinence nor in decreases in cocaine intake in addicted individuals actively using the drug. Instead, NAC prevented the return to cocaine use in patients that had already achieved abstinence.
Neurobiologically, in extinction-reinstatement procedures, treatment with NAC has been shown in rats to reverse cocaine-induced glutamatergic adaptations selectively in the AcbC (
1The glutamate homeostasis hypothesis of addiction.
), where pharmacogenetically induced astrocytic release of glutamate also decreases cue-induced reinstatement of instrumental responding for cocaine (
22- Scofield M.D.
- Boger H.A.
- Smith R.J.
- Li H.
- Haydon P.G.
- Kalivas P.W.
Gq-DREADD selectively initiates glial glutamate release and inhibits cue-induced cocaine seeking.
). Thus, NAC increases glial expression of the cysteine/glutamate antiporter and glutamate type 1 transporter (GLT1), thereby restoring extracellular levels of glutamate (
11- Kupchik Y.
- Moussawi K.
- Tang X.
- Wang X.
- Kalivas B.
- Kolokithas R.
- et al.
The effect of N-acetylcysteine in the nucleus accumbens on neurotransmission and relapse to cocaine.
,
23- Moussawi K.
- Pacchioni A.
- Moran M.
- Olive M.
- Gass J.
- Lavin A.
- Kalivas P.W.
N-Acetylcysteine reverses cocaine-induced metaplasticity.
) and decreasing excitatory synaptic transmission in the AcbC. However, studies based on acute exposure to cocaine SA followed by extinction may not fully capture the nature of addiction that does not result from an adaptation merely to short-term exposure to the drug under continuous reinforcement (
18- Belin-Rauscent A.
- Fouyssac M.
- Bonci A.
- Belin D.
How preclinical models evolved to resemble the diagnostic criteria of drug addiction.
). Instead, it involves the progressive development of compulsive drug seeking and loss of control over drug intake (
24- Belin D.
- Belin-Rauscent A.
- Murray J.E.
- Everitt B.J.
Addiction: Failure of control over maladaptive incentive habits.
), the neurobiological substrates of which encompass both the ventral striatum and the dorsolateral striatum (DLS) in humans (
25- Vollstadt-Klein S.
- Wichert S.
- Rabinstein J.
- Buhler M.
- Klein O.
- Ende G.
- et al.
Initial, habitual and compulsive alcohol use is characterized by a shift of cue processing from ventral to dorsal striatum.
,
26- Xie C.
- Shao Y.
- Ma L.
- Zhai T.
- Ye E.
- Fu L.
- et al.
Imbalanced functional link between valuation networks in abstinent heroin-dependent subjects.
) and in preclinical models (
27Cocaine seeking habits depend upon dopamine-dependent serial connectivity linking the ventral with the dorsal striatum.
,
28- Hollander J.
- Im H.
- Amelio A.
- Kocerha J.
- Bali P.
- Lu Q.
- et al.
Striatal microRNA controls cocaine intake through CREB signalling.
,
29- Zapata A.
- Minney V.
- Shippenberg T.
Shift from goal-directed to habitual cocaine seeking after prolonged experience in rats.
,
30- Willuhn I.
- Burgeno L.
- Everitt B.
- Phillips P.
Hierarchical recruitment of phasic dopamine signaling in the striatum during the progression of cocaine use.
).
Discussion
This study investigated the effects of chronic NAC treatment on rats given extended access to cocaine, which resulted in their showing hallmark features of cocaine addiction, namely loss of control over drug intake, increased motivation for the drug, and maintained drug use despite adverse consequences (
18- Belin-Rauscent A.
- Fouyssac M.
- Bonci A.
- Belin D.
How preclinical models evolved to resemble the diagnostic criteria of drug addiction.
). Chronic treatment with NAC had no measurable effect on the progression of loss of control in rats that had already developed escalated cocaine SA or on the motivation for the drug measured under a progressive ratio schedule of reinforcement. This observation is in contrast with the previous demonstration that chronic NAC treatment prevents the escalation of cocaine self-administration (
13- Madayag A.
- Lobner D.
- Kau K.
- Mantsch J.
- Abdulhameed O.
- Hearing M.
- et al.
Repeated N-acetylcysteine administration alters plasticity-dependent effects of cocaine.
). This discrepancy may stem from several differences between the two studies including the training history of the animals, the unit dose of cocaine, and the time point at which NAC treatment was initiated. Thus, in the present study, rats acquired instrumental responding for cocaine infusions (.8 mg/kg in 100 µL) under short access, FR1 schedule of reinforcement for 7 days before being exposed to 6-hour extended access or maintained under short access conditions. In the previous study, rats received unit infusions of .5 mg/kg in 200 µL, a unit dose and delivery rate both shown to greatly influence various behavioral features of cocaine self-administration, including motivation (
40- Allain F.
- Minogianis E.A.
- Roberts D.C.
- Samaha A.N.
How fast and how often: The pharmacokinetics of drug use are decisive in addiction.
). More importantly, whereas the rats of the previous study received daily NAC treatment from the first of the 12 days of differential access to cocaine, i.e., from the first session of extended access for the LgA group, in this study rats were allowed 19 extended access sessions to develop a robust escalation of cocaine SA before receiving NAC treatment. In this study, we were more interested in the influence of NAC on the maintenance of escalated cocaine SA in rats suggested to resemble addicted individuals and not in the development of escalation, which represents a prodromal stage of addiction and hence may not be a suitable target for therapeutic intervention. Thus, while NAC treatment interacts with the neurobiological mechanisms involved in the development of escalation of cocaine SA (
13- Madayag A.
- Lobner D.
- Kau K.
- Mantsch J.
- Abdulhameed O.
- Hearing M.
- et al.
Repeated N-acetylcysteine administration alters plasticity-dependent effects of cocaine.
), it does not influence its maintenance. This observation is in line with human studies that have revealed that NAC treatment does not decrease ongoing cocaine use (
4- LaRowe S.
- Kalivas P.
- Nicholas J.
- Randall P.
- Mardikian P.
- Malcolm R.
A double-blind placebo-controlled trial of N-acetylcysteine in the treatment of cocaine dependence.
).
However, chronic NAC treatment in rats showing escalated cocaine intake dramatically reduced compulsivity by enabling LgA rats to withhold responding in the face of punishment, thereby achieving abstinence more readily. Not only did NAC-treated LgA rats display a faster decrease in cocaine SA than Veh-treated LgA rats in the presence of contingent punishment, they also never fully recovered their prepunishment level of cocaine intake over the course of the five subsequent baseline sessions. This decrease in intake following punishment when the drug was again made available at no cost suggests that NAC not only facilitated the establishment of abstinence in the face of adverse consequences but also promoted long-term reduction in intake. This was paralleled by a marked increase in the latency to complete the first FR5 sequence leading to cocaine infusions over the five postpunishment sessions, suggesting that NAC-treated LgA rats displayed an increased propensity to inhibit the drug-seeking instrumental sequence for a longer period of time postpunishment than Veh-treated LgA rats.
This effect of NAC on the sensitivity to the aversive consequences of cocaine SA observed only in LgA rats is attributable neither to the differential access to the drug nor to a direct pharmacologic effect of NAC on pain thresholds. Indeed, the emergence of compulsive cocaine SA has recently been shown not to be associated with an increase in pain threshold (
41Vanhille N, Ducret E, Puaud M, Ansquer S, Fouyssac M, Houeto J, et al. (2013): C.20 - Differential effect of environmental enrichment on the acquisition of drug use and the transition to addiction. Presented at the 15th Biennal Meeting of the European Behavioural Pharmacology Society, September 6-9, La Rochelle, France.
), an effect consistent with evidence that enhanced resistance to conditioned suppression after an extended cocaine SA history is not related to individual sensitivity to the aversive properties of the shock (
42- Vanderschuren L.J.
- Everitt B.J.
Drug seeking becomes compulsive after prolonged cocaine self-administration.
). Additionally, NAC diminishes the sensitivity to painful stimuli (
43- Chu C.
- Levine E.
- Gear R.W.
- Bogen O.
- Levine J.D.
Mitochondrial dependence of nerve growth factor-induced mechanical hyperalgesia.
,
44- Naik A.K.
- Tandan S.K.
- Dudhgaonkar S.P.
- Jadhav S.H.
- Kataria M.
- Prakash V.R.
- Kumar D.
Role of oxidative stress in pathophysiology of peripheral neuropathy and modulation by N-acetyl-L-cysteine in rats.
), i.e., increases pain thresholds so that if the effect of NAC was dependent on its effect on pain mechanisms, a decrease in, rather than a potentiation of, the suppression of instrumental responding during punishment under NAC treatment would be expected, and this would be generalized both to ShA and LgA rats.
The promotion of restored control induced by NAC in LgA rats was independent of any alteration in the motivation for cocaine as measured by the breakpoint under a progressive ratio schedule of reinforcement. Moreover, the breakpoint and the suppression of cocaine intake following punishment were not correlated. These data are in agreement with the previous demonstration that NAC reduces cue-controlled cocaine seeking without altering cocaine intake under a second-order schedule of reinforcement (
6- Murray J.
- Everitt B.
- Belin D.
N-Acetylcysteine reduces early- and late-stage cocaine seeking without affecting cocaine taking in rats.
), suggesting that NAC has no effect on the reinforcing properties of cocaine despite the increased propensity to lever press under a progressive ratio schedule of reinforcement shown by LgA rats as compared with ShA rats.
Thus, NAC may enhance the long-lasting effects of being exposed to the punishment of responding for cocaine on the subsequent propensity to resume drug use but only in individuals that have lost control over intake. Indeed, LgA rats displayed the key behavioral characteristics of cocaine addiction: they developed a daily increase in their intake, so-called escalation of cocaine SA (
16- Dilleen R.
- Pelloux Y.
- Mar A.
- Molander A.
- Robbins T.
- Everitt B.
- et al.
High anxiety is a predisposing endophenotype for loss of control over cocaine, but not heroin, self-administration in rats.
,
19Transition from moderate to excessive drug intake: Change in hedonic set point.
); they displayed an apparent increased motivation for cocaine as compared with ShA rats consistent with previous studies (
45- Hao Y.
- Martin-Fardon R.
- Weiss F.
Behavioral and functional evidence of metabotropic glutamate receptor 2/3 and metabotropic glutamate receptor 5 dysregulation in cocaine-escalated rats: Factor in the transition to dependence.
,
46- Specio S.E.
- Wee S.
- O’Dell L.E.
- Boutrel B.
- Zorrilla E.P.
- Koob G.F.
CRF(1) receptor antagonists attenuate escalated cocaine self-administration in rats.
,
47- Orio L.
- Edwards S.
- George O.
- Parsons L.H.
- Koob G.F.
A role for the endocannabinoid system in the increased motivation for cocaine in extended-access conditions.
); and they were less sensitive to punishment than ShA rats during the first punishment session, thereby revealing the compulsive nature of their cocaine SA (
18- Belin-Rauscent A.
- Fouyssac M.
- Bonci A.
- Belin D.
How preclinical models evolved to resemble the diagnostic criteria of drug addiction.
).
Protracted exposure to extended access to cocaine, in conditions similar to those in the present experiment, triggered an almost complete resistance to probabilistic punishment in a subset of a population of rats tested in a seeking-taking chained schedule of reinforcement (
48- Pelloux Y.
- Everitt B.J.
- Dickinson A.
Compulsive drug seeking by rats under punishment: Effects of drug taking history.
). The greater sensitivity to punishment in the present experiment may be attributed to the nature of the punishment applied [see (
18- Belin-Rauscent A.
- Fouyssac M.
- Bonci A.
- Belin D.
How preclinical models evolved to resemble the diagnostic criteria of drug addiction.
,
21- Belin D.
- Deroche-Gamonet V.
Responses to novelty and vulnerability to cocaine addiction: Contribution of a multi-symptomatic animal model.
) for more details]. In the procedure used here, the animal does not risk punishment to gain access to the drug, as is the case in probabilistic punishment paradigms, but instead it must endure at least two shocks before every single infusion, making the latter punishment schedule more aversive than the former. Nevertheless, as previously described (
48- Pelloux Y.
- Everitt B.J.
- Dickinson A.
Compulsive drug seeking by rats under punishment: Effects of drug taking history.
,
49- Jonkman S.
- Pelloux Y.
- Everitt B.
Drug intake is sufficient, but conditioning is not necessary for the emergence of compulsive cocaine seeking after extended self-administration.
), extended access to the drug facilitated the emergence of compulsive cocaine self-administration. In drug-addicted humans, voluntary abstinence usually arises only after repeated exposure to adverse consequences of drug use (
50- Waldorf D.
- Reinarman C.
- Murphy S.
Cocaine Changes: The Experience of Using and Quitting.
). Even though initially resisting punishment more than ShA rats, LgA rats developed complete abstinence after three repeated punishment sessions. This withholding of responses, or abstinence, in the presence of adverse consequences has been suggested to have face and ecological validity (
18- Belin-Rauscent A.
- Fouyssac M.
- Bonci A.
- Belin D.
How preclinical models evolved to resemble the diagnostic criteria of drug addiction.
,
51- Economidou D.
- Pelloux Y.
- Robbins T.
- Dalley J.
- Everitt B.
High impulsivity predicts relapse to cocaine-seeking after punishment-induced abstinence.
).
At the neurobiological level, cocaine exposure resulted in an access-dependent decrease in GLT1 both in the AcbC, as previously described (
14- Fischer K.D.
- Houston A.C.
- Rebec G.V.
Role of the major glutamate transporter GLT1 in nucleus accumbens core versus shell in cue-induced cocaine-seeking behavior.
,
52- Fischer-Smith K.D.
- Houston A.C.
- Rebec G.V.
Differential effects of cocaine access and withdrawal on glutamate type 1 transporter expression in rat nucleus accumbens core and shell.
), and in the DLS. The access-dependent decrease in GLT1 was quantitatively similar between the AcbC and the DLS and was reversed in both striatal territories by chronic NAC treatment. This influence of NAC on GLT1 protein levels had already been shown to occur in the AcbC (
2- Brown R.M.
- Kupchik Y.M.
- Kalivas P.W.
The story of glutamate in drug addiction and of N-acetylcysteine as a potential pharmacotherapy.
,
11- Kupchik Y.
- Moussawi K.
- Tang X.
- Wang X.
- Kalivas B.
- Kolokithas R.
- et al.
The effect of N-acetylcysteine in the nucleus accumbens on neurotransmission and relapse to cocaine.
,
14- Fischer K.D.
- Houston A.C.
- Rebec G.V.
Role of the major glutamate transporter GLT1 in nucleus accumbens core versus shell in cue-induced cocaine-seeking behavior.
,
53Astrocytic dysfunction and addiction: Consequences of impaired glutamate homeostasis.
) but not in the DLS. In this study, protein levels were quantified in rats having been given access to cocaine under baseline conditions after having voluntarily withheld self-administering responses in the face of punishment. Additionally, neither Zif268 nor GLT1 protein levels correlated with cocaine intake or instrumental performance overall or during the punished or subsequent baseline sessions. Thus, while this study identifies the DLS as an additional site at which NAC regulates glutamate homeostasis and cellular plasticity mechanisms while contributing to restoration of control over cocaine intake in addicted individuals, it does not allow any inference about a causal relationship between the molecular and behavioral readouts. Future research is warranted to identify the cascade of cellular and molecular events, such as alteration of the cysteine-glutamate exchanger (
54- Moran M.
- McFarland K.
- Melendez R.
- Kalivas P.
- Seamans J.
Cystine/glutamate exchange regulates metabotropic glutamate receptor presynaptic inhibition of excitatory transmission and vulnerability to cocaine seeking.
) and metabotropic glutamate receptors levels (
55Glutamate: The new frontier in pharmacotherapy for cocaine addiction.
) that lead chronic NAC treatment eventually to facilitate self-initiated abstinence and subsequent restoration of control over intake.
Nevertheless, the influence of cocaine exposure on the progressive decrease in GLT1 protein levels in the DLS and its reversal by NAC is in line with the evidence that NAC diminishes habitual control over behavior (
56- Corbit L.H.
- Chieng B.C.
- Balleine B.W.
Effects of repeated cocaine exposure on habit learning and reversal by N-acetylcysteine.
), which is dependent upon the DLS (
57- Yin H.H.
- Knowlton B.J.
- Balleine B.W.
Lesions of dorsolateral striatum preserve outcome expectancy but disrupt habit formation in instrumental learning.
), and our previous demonstration that NAC dose-dependently decreases habitual cocaine seeking in rats trained extensively to seek cocaine under the control of drug-associated conditioned stimuli (
6- Murray J.
- Everitt B.
- Belin D.
N-Acetylcysteine reduces early- and late-stage cocaine seeking without affecting cocaine taking in rats.
). These conditions are known to trigger a shift in the neural locus of control over seeking responses from the ventral striatum to the DLS involving both glutamatergic and dopaminergic mechanisms (
6- Murray J.
- Everitt B.
- Belin D.
N-Acetylcysteine reduces early- and late-stage cocaine seeking without affecting cocaine taking in rats.
,
27Cocaine seeking habits depend upon dopamine-dependent serial connectivity linking the ventral with the dorsal striatum.
,
58- Vanderschuren L.
- Di Ciano P.
- Everitt B.
Involvement of the dorsal striatum in cue-controlled cocaine seeking.
). The devolution of control over cocaine seeking to the DLS is also associated with the development of compulsive cocaine seeking (
59- Jonkman S.
- Pelloux Y.
- Everitt B.
Differential roles of the dorsolateral and midlateral striatum in punished cocaine seeking.
), which is facilitated in rats with a history of escalated cocaine self-administration (
48- Pelloux Y.
- Everitt B.J.
- Dickinson A.
Compulsive drug seeking by rats under punishment: Effects of drug taking history.
).
This ventral to dorsal striatal shift in the locus of control over compulsive drug seeking has also been shown in drug-addicted individuals (
25- Vollstadt-Klein S.
- Wichert S.
- Rabinstein J.
- Buhler M.
- Klein O.
- Ende G.
- et al.
Initial, habitual and compulsive alcohol use is characterized by a shift of cue processing from ventral to dorsal striatum.
) who also display an increased functional connectivity between the AcbC and DLS (
26- Xie C.
- Shao Y.
- Ma L.
- Zhai T.
- Ye E.
- Fu L.
- et al.
Imbalanced functional link between valuation networks in abstinent heroin-dependent subjects.
), suggested to be triggered by drug exposure (
60- Takahashi Y.
- Schoenbaum G.
- Niv Y.
Silencing the critics: Understanding the effects of cocaine sensitization on dorsolateral and ventral striatum in the context of an actor/critic model.
). This view is compatible with the influence of NAC treatment on cocaine-induced alterations in the protein levels of the cellular plasticity marker Zif268 (
35- Valjent E.
- Aubier B.
- Corbille A.G.
- Brami-Cherrier K.
- Caboche J.
- Topilko P.
- et al.
Plasticity-associated gene Krox24/Zif268 is required for long-lasting behavioral effects of cocaine.
) observed between short and extended cocaine exposures that were independent of GLT1 protein levels, as revealed by a lack of correlation between the two markers in both the AcbC and DLS. Thus, while NAC reversed the increase in Zif268 observed in the AcbC and the DLS following short access to cocaine, it abolished the decrease in Zif268 observed in both striatal territories following extended access. These data suggest that the neurobiological locus underlying the behavioral effects of NAC in addicted rats lies both in the AcbC and DLS in which cellular Zif268-dependent plasticity mechanisms, involved in instrumental learning and the long-term cellular effects of cocaine (
31- Maroteaux M.
- Valjent E.
- Longueville S.
- Topilko P.
- Girault J.A.
- Herve D.
Role of the plasticity-associated transcription factor zif268 in the early phase of instrumental learning.
,
32- Veyrac A.
- Besnard A.
- Caboche J.
- Davis S.
- Laroche S.
The transcription factor Zif268/Egr1, brain plasticity, and memory.
,
33- Unal C.T.
- Beverley J.A.
- Willuhn I.
- Steiner H.
Long-lasting dysregulation of gene expression in corticostriatal circuits after repeated cocaine treatment in adult rats: Effects on zif 268 and homer 1a.
,
34A gene for neuronal plasticity in the mammalian brain: Zif268/Egr-1/NGFI-A/Krox-24/TIS8/ZENK?.
,
35- Valjent E.
- Aubier B.
- Corbille A.G.
- Brami-Cherrier K.
- Caboche J.
- Topilko P.
- et al.
Plasticity-associated gene Krox24/Zif268 is required for long-lasting behavioral effects of cocaine.
,
36- Moratalla R.
- Robertson H.
- Graybiel A.
Dynamic regulation of NGFI-A (zif268, egr1) gene expression in the striatum.
), are differentially regulated by short or extended access to cocaine. Thus, short access to cocaine results in similar increases in Zif268-associated cellular plasticity mechanisms in the AcbC and DLS that may reflect drug-induced striatal plasticity mechanisms subserving the early effects of cocaine exposure. However, under extended access conditions, when rats lose control over cocaine self-administration, becoming compulsive, the striatal system may become resilient to cocaine-induced cellular plasticity as previously described (
61- Kasanetz F.
- Deroche-Gamonet V.
- Berson N.
- Balado E.
- Lafourcade M.
- Manzoni O.
- et al.
Transition to addiction is associated with a persistent impairment in synaptic plasticity.
), so-called anaplasticity, which could be related with the persistence of an aberrant functional coupling between the ventral striatum and the DLS, also seen in drug-addicted humans (
25- Vollstadt-Klein S.
- Wichert S.
- Rabinstein J.
- Buhler M.
- Klein O.
- Ende G.
- et al.
Initial, habitual and compulsive alcohol use is characterized by a shift of cue processing from ventral to dorsal striatum.
), that is disrupted by NAC treatment. As a consequence, animals may re-establish control over their drug-seeking habits, illustrated in this study by the increased time NAC-LgA rats take to perform their first cocaine-seeking sequence in the sessions that follow their self-imposed abstinence.
If the reorganization of glutamatergic function brought about by NAC treatment in both the ventral striatum and DSL provides a mechanism by which control over drug intake can be regained, then other defining features of addiction may also be attenuated.
Acknowledgments and Disclosures
This research was supported by a French Institute of Health and Medical Research Avenir and an ANR12 SAMA00201 Grant (to DB) as well as a Newton Trust/Cambridge University Grant (to DB). BJE and JEM are supported by a Medical Research Council (G9536855, G0701500) Grant to BJE and by a joint award from the Medical Research Council and Wellcome Trust in support of the Behavioral and Clinical Neuroscience Institute at Cambridge University.
DB supervised the research. DB, EDuc, MP, JL, BJE, and J-LH designed the experiment. EDuc, MP, and JL performed the behavioral experiments. JEM and DB performed the surgeries. MP and EDug performed the Western blot experiments. EDuc, AB-R, MF, and MP analyzed the data. EDuc, AB-R, J-LH, JEM, BJE, and DB wrote the manuscript.
We thank Pr Guylène Page for her technical support, as well as Khadra Escriva and Laurence Turi for their precious help in the animal facility of Poitiers.
The authors declare no biomedical financial interests or potential conflicts of interest.