Advertisement

Context, ambiguity, and unlearning: sources of relapse after behavioral extinction

  • Mark E Bouton
    Correspondence
    Address reprint requests to Mark E. Bouton, Ph.D., Department of Psychology, University of Vermont, Burlington VT 05405-0134, USA.
    Affiliations
    Department of Psychology, University of Vermont, Burlington, Vermont, USA
    Search for articles by this author

      Abstract

      There is now ample evidence that extinction, the loss of learned performance that occurs when a Pavlovian signal or an instrumental action is repeatedly presented without its reinforcer, does not reflect a destruction of the original learning. This article summarizes the evidence and extends and updates earlier reviews. The main alternative to “unlearning” is the idea that extinction (as well as other retroactive interference processes, including counterconditioning) involves new learning that is stored along with the old. One consequence is that the Pavlovian signal or instrumental action has two available “meanings” and thus has the properties of an ambiguous word: its current meaning (and the resulting behavioral output) depends on what the current context retrieves. Contexts can be provided by a variety of background stimuli, including the physical environment, internal drug state, and time. The second thing learned (e.g., extinction, counterconditioning) seems especially dependent on the context for retrieval. A variety of evidence is consistent with this analysis, which highlights several important sources of relapse after extinction. The article concludes with several issues for future research, among them the question of how we can optimize extinction and other putative “unlearning” treatments so as to prevent the various forms of relapse discussed here.

      Keywords

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to Biological Psychiatry
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Ahlers S.T.
        • Richardson R.
        Administration of dexamethasone prior to training blocks ACTH-induced recovery of an extinguished avoidance response.
        Behav Neurosci. 1985; 99: 760-764
        • Baker A.G.
        • Steinwald H.
        • Bouton M.E.
        • et al.
        Contextual conditioning and reinstatement of extinguished instrumental responding.
        Q J Exper Psychol. 1991; 43B: 199-218
        • Bouton M.E.
        Differential control by context in the inflation and reinstatement paradigms.
        J Exper Psychol: Anim Behav Processes. 1984; 10: 56-74
        • Bouton M.E.
        Slow reacquisition following the extinction of conditioned suppression.
        Learn Motiv. 1986; 17: 1-15
        • Bouton M.E.
        Context and ambiguity in the extinction of emotional learning.
        Behav Res Ther. 1988; 26: 137-149
        • Bouton M.E.
        Context time and memory retrieval in the interference paradigms of Pavlovian learning.
        Psychol Bull. 1993; 114: 80-99
        • Bouton M.E.
        Conditioning remembering and forgetting.
        J Exper Psychol: Anim Behav Processes. 1994; 20: 219-231
        • Bouton M.E.
        A learning theory perspective on lapse relapse and the maintenance of behavior change.
        Health Psychol. 2000; 19: 57-63
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Bolles R.C.
        Contextual control of the extinction of conditioned fear.
        Learn Motiv. 1979; 10: 445-466
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Bolles R.C.
        Role of conditioned contextual stimuli in reinstatement of extinguished fear.
        J Exper Psychol: Anim Behav Processes. 1979; 5: 368-378
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Bolles R.C.
        Contexts event-memories and extinction.
        in: Balsam P.D. Tomie A. Context and Learning. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ1985: 133-166
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Brooks D.C.
        Time and context effects on performance in a Pavlovian discrimination reversal.
        J Exper Psychol: Anim Behav Processes. 1993; 19: 165-179
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Kenney F.A.
        • Rosengard C.
        • et al.
        State-dependent fear extinction with two benzodiazepine tranquilizers.
        Behav Neurosci. 1990; 104: 44-55
        • Bouton M.E.
        • King D.A.
        Contextual control of the extinction of conditioned fear.
        J Exper Psychol: Anim Behav Processes. 1983; 9: 248-265
        • Bouton M.E.
        • King D.A.
        Effect of context on performance to conditioned stimuli with mixed histories of reinforcement and nonreinforcement.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 1986; 12: 4-15
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Nelson J.B.
        Context-specificity of target versus feature inhibition in a feature-negative discrimination.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 1994; 20: 51-65
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Nelson J.B.
        The role of context in classical conditioning.
        in: O’Donohue W. Learning and Behavior Therapy. Allyn and Bacon, Needham Heights, MA1998: 59-84
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Nelson J.B.
        • Rosas J.M.
        • et al.
        Stimulus generalization context change and forgetting.
        Psychol Bull. 1999; 125: 171-186
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Peck C.A.
        Context effects on conditioning extinction and reinstatement in an appetitive conditioning preparation.
        Anim Learn Behav. 1989; 17: 188-198
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Peck C.A.
        Spontaneous recovery in cross-motivational transfer (counterconditioning).
        Anim Learning Behav. 1992; 20: 313-321
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Ricker S.T.
        Renewal of extinguished responding in a second context.
        Anim Learn Behav. 1994; 22: 317-324
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Rosengard C.
        • Achenbach G.G.
        • Peck C.A.
        • Brooks D.C.
        • et al.
        Effects of contextual conditioning and unconditional stimulus presentation on performance in appetitive conditioning.
        Q J Exper Psychol. 1993; 46B: 63-95
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Swartzentruber D.
        Slow reacquisition following extinction.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 1989; 15: 43-53
        • Bouton M.E.
        • Swartzentruber D.
        Sources of relapse after extinction in Pavlovian and instrumental learning.
        Clin Psychol Rev. 1991; 11: 123-140
        • Bower G.H.
        Mood and memory.
        Am Psychol. 1981; 36: 129-148
        • Brooks D.C.
        Recent and remote extinction cues reduce spontaneous recovery.
        Q J Exper Psycho. 2000; l53B: 25-58
        • Brooks D.C.
        • Bouton M.E.
        A retrieval cue for extinction attenuates spontaneous recovery.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 1993; 19: 77-89
        • Brooks D.C.
        • Bouton M.E.
        A retrieval cue for extinction attenuates response recovery (renewal) caused by a return to the conditioning context.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 1994; 20: 366-379
        • Brooks D.C.
        • Bowker J.L.
        Further evidence that conditioned inhibition is not the mechanism of an extinction cue’s effect.
        Anim Learn Behav. 2001; 29: 381-388
        • Brooks D.C.
        • Hale B.
        • Nelson J.B.
        • Bouton M.E.
        • et al.
        Reinstatement after counterconditioning.
        Anim Learn Behav. 1995; 23: 383-390
        • Brooks D.C.
        • Karamanlian B.R.
        • Foster V.L.
        • et al.
        Extinction and spontaneous recovery of ataxic tolerance to ethanol in rats.
        Psychopharmacology. 2001; 153: 491-496
        • Brooks D.C.
        • Palmatier M.I.
        • Garcia E.O.
        • Johnson J.L.
        • et al.
        An extinction cue reduces spontaneous recovery of a conditioned taste aversion.
        Anim Learn Behav. 1999; 27: 77-88
        • Calton J.L.
        • Mitchell K.G.
        • Schachtman T.R.
        • et al.
        Conditioned inhibition produced by extinction of a conditioned stimulus.
        Learn Motiv. 1996; 27: 335-361
        • Campeau S.
        • Miserendino M.J.D.
        • Davis M.
        • et al.
        Intra-amygdala infusion of the N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor antagonist AP5 blocks acquisition but not expression of fear-potentiated startle to an auditory conditioned stimulus.
        Behav Neurosci. 1992; 106: 569-574
        • Capaldi E.J.
        The sequential view.
        Psychonomic Bull Rev. 1994; 1: 156-181
        • Chelonis J.J.
        • Calton J.L.
        • Hart J.A.
        • Schachtman T.R.
        • et al.
        Attenuation of the renewal effect by extinction in multiple contexts.
        Learn Motiv. 1999; 30: 1-14
        • Collins B.N.
        • Brandon T.H.
        Effects of extinction context and retrieval cues on alcohol cue reactivity among nonalcoholic drinkers.
        J Consult Clin Psychol. 2002; 70: 390-397
        • Crombag H.S.
        • Shaham Y.
        Renewal of drug seeking by contextual cues after prolonged extinction in rats.
        Behav Neurosci. 2002; 116: 169-173
        • Cunningham C.L.
        Alcohol as a cue for extinction.
        Anim Learn Behav. 1979; 7: 45-52
        • Davidson T.L.
        The nature and function of interoceptive signals to feed.
        Psychol Rev. 1993; 100: 640-657
        • Delamater A.R.
        Selective reinstatement of stimulus-outcome associations.
        Anim Learn Behav. 1997; 25: 400-412
        • Devenport L.
        • Hill T.
        • Wilson M.
        • Ogden E.
        • et al.
        Tracking and averaging in variable environments.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 1997; 23: 450-460
        • De Wit H.
        • Stewart J.
        Reinstatement of cocaine-reinforced responding in the rat.
        Psychopharmacology. 1981; 75: 134-143
        • Eich E.
        Searching for mood dependent memory.
        Psychol Sci. 1995; 6: 67-75
        • Estes W.K.
        Statistical theory of spontaneous recovery and regression.
        Psychol Rev. 1955; 62: 145-154
        • Falls W.A.
        Extinction.
        in: O’Donohue W. Learning and Behavior Therapy. Allyn and Bacon, Boston1998: 205-229
        • Falls W.A.
        • Miserendino M.J.
        • Davis M.
        • et al.
        Extinction of fear-potentiated startle.
        J Neurosci. 1992; 12: 854-863
        • Frohardt R.J.
        • Guarraci F.A.
        • Bouton M.E.
        • et al.
        The effects of neurotoxic hippocampal lesions on two effects of context after fear extinction.
        Behav Neurosci. 2000; 114: 227-240
        • Glenberg A.M.
        Monotonic and nonmonotonic lag effects in paired-associate and recognition memory paradigms.
        J Verbal Learn Verbal Behav. 1976; 15: 1-16
        • Gunther L.M.
        • Denniston J.C.
        • Miller R.R.
        • et al.
        Conducting exposure treatment in multiple contexts can prevent relapse.
        Behav Res Ther. 1998; 36: 75-91
        • Harris J.A.
        • Jones M.L.
        • Bailey G.K.
        • Westbrook R.F.
        • et al.
        Contextual control over conditioned responding in an extinction paradigm.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 2000; 26: 174-185
        • Hart J.A.
        • Bourne M.J.
        • Schachtman T.R.
        • et al.
        Slow reacquisition of a conditioned taste aversion.
        Anim Learn Behav. 1995; 23: 297-303
        • Hiss H.
        • Foa E.B.
        • Kozak M.J.
        • et al.
        Relapse prevention program for treatment of obsessive-compulsive disorder.
        J Consult Clin Psycho. 1994; l62: 801-808
        • Kehoe E.J.
        • Macrae M.
        Savings in animal learning.
        Behav Ther. 1997; 28: 141-155
        • Konorski J.
        Conditioned Reflexes and Neuron Organization. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK1948
        • Kushner M.G.
        • Abrams K.
        • Borchardt C.
        • et al.
        The relationship between anxiety disorders and alcohol use disorders.
        Clin Psychol Rev. 2000; 20: 149-171
        • Lang A.J.
        • Craske M.G.
        • Bjork R.A.
        • et al.
        Implications of a new theory of disuse for the treatment of emotional disorders.
        Clin Psychol Sci Practice. 1999; 6: 80-94
        • Lattal K.M.
        • Abel T.
        Different requirements for protein synthesis in acquisition and extinction of spatial preferences and context-evoked fear.
        J Neurosci. 2001; 21: 5773-5780
        • Lee H.
        • Kim J.J.
        Amygdalar NMDA receptors are critical for new fear learning in previously fear-conditioned rats.
        J Neurosci. 1998; 18: 8444-8454
        • Lu K.T.
        • Walker D.L.
        • Davis M.
        • et al.
        Mitogen-activated protein kinase cascade in the basolateral nucleus of amygdala is involved in extinction of fear-potentiated startle.
        J Neurosci. 2001; 21: RC162
        • McClelland J.L.
        • Rumelhart D.E.
        Distributed memory and the representation of general and specific information.
        J Exper Psychol Gen. 1985; 114: 159-188
        • McCloskey M.
        • Cohen N.J.
        Catastrophic interference in connectionist networks.
        in: Bower G.H. The Psychology of Learning and Motivation. Academic Press, San Diego, CA1989: 109-165 (Vol. 24)
        • Mineka S.
        • Mystkowski J.L.
        • Hladek D.
        • Rodriguez B.I.
        • et al.
        The effects of changing contexts on return of fear following exposure therapy for spider fear.
        J Consult Clin Psycho. 1999; l67: 599-604
        • Miserendino M.J.D.
        • Sananes C.B.
        • Melia K.R.
        • Davis M.
        • et al.
        Blocking of acquisition but not expression of conditioned fear-potentiated startle by NMDA antagonists in the amygdal.
        Nature. 1990; 345: 716-718
        • Mystkowski JL
        • Craske MG
        • Echiverri AM
        • et al.
        Treatment context and return of fear in spider phobia.
        Behav Ther. 2002; 33: 399-416
        • Nakajima S.
        • Tanaka S.
        • Urshihara K.
        • Imada H.
        • et al.
        Renewal of extinguished lever-press responses upon return to the training context.
        Learn Motiv. 2000; 31: 416-431
        • Napier R.M.
        • Macrae M.
        • Kehoe E.J.
        • et al.
        Rapid reacquisition in conditioning of the rabbit’s nictitating membrane response.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 1992; 18: 182-192
        • Nelson J.B.
        Context specificity of excitation and inhibition in ambiguous stimuli.
        Learn Motiv. 2002; 33: 284-310
        • Nelson J.B.
        • Bouton M.E.
        Extinction inhibition and emotional intelligence.
        in: Feldman Barrett L. Salovey P. The Wisdom in Feeling Psychological Processes in Emotional Intelligence. Guilford, New York2002: 60-85
        • Overton D.A.
        Contextual stimulus effects of drugs and internal states.
        in: Balsam P.D. Tomie A. Context and Learning. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ1985: 357-384
        • Pavlov I.P.
        Conditioned Reflexes. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK1927
        • Pearce J.M.
        • Hall G.
        A model for Pavlovian conditioning.
        Psychol Rev. 1980; 87: 332-352
        • Peck C.A.
        • Bouton M.E.
        Context and performance in aversive-to-appetitive and appetitive-to-aversive transfer.
        Learn Motiv. 1990; 21: 1-31
        • Rachman S.J.
        The return of fear.
        Behav Res Ther. 1979; 17: 164-165
        • Rachman S.J.
        The return of fear.
        Clin Psychol Rev. 1989; 9: 147-168
        • Rauhut A.S.
        • Thomas B.L.
        • Ayres J.J.B.
        • et al.
        Treatments that weaken Pavlovian conditioned fear and thwart its renewal in rats.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 2001; 27: 99-114
        • Reid R.L.
        The role of the reinforcer as a stimulus.
        Br J Psychol. 1958; 49: 202-209
        • Rescorla R.A.
        Effect of US habituation following conditioning.
        J Comp Physiol Psycho. 1973; l82: 137-143
        • Rescorla R.A.
        Preservation of response-outcome associations through extinction.
        Anim Learn Behav. 1993; 21: 238-245
        • Rescorla R.A.
        Preservation of Pavlovian associations through extinction.
        Q J Exper Psychol. 1996; 49B: 245-258
        • Rescorla R.A.
        Experimental extinction.
        in: Mowrer R.R. Klein S.B. Handbook of Contemporary Learning Theories. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ2001: 119-154
        • Rescorla R.A.
        • Cunningham C.L.
        The erasure of reinstated fear.
        Anim Learn Behav. 1972; 5: 386-394
        • Rescorla R.A.
        • Heth C.D.
        Reinstatement of fear to an extinguished conditioned stimulus.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 1975; 1: 88-96
        • Rescorla R.A.
        • Wagner A.R.
        A theory of Pavlovian conditioning.
        in: Black A.H. Prokasy W.K. Classical Conditioning II Current Research and Theory. Appleton-Century-Crofts, New York1972
        • Ricker S.T.
        • Bouton M.E.
        Reacquisition following extinction in appetitive conditioning.
        Anim Learn Behav. 1996; 24: 423-436
        • Robbins S.J.
        Mechanisms underlying spontaneous recovery in autoshaping.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 1990; 16: 235-249
        • Rodriguez B.I.
        • Craske M.G.
        • Mineka S.
        • Hladek D.
        • et al.
        Context-specificity of relapse.
        Behav Res Ther. 1999; 37: 845-862
        • Rosas J.M.
        • Bouton M.E.
        Context change and retention interval can have additive rather than interactive effects after taste aversion extinction.
        Psychonomic Bull Rev. 1998; 5: 79-83
        • Rosas J.M.
        • Vila N.J.
        • Lugo M.
        • López L.
        • et al.
        Combined effect of context change and retention interval on interference in causality judgments.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 2001; 27: 153-164
        • Rowe M.K.
        • Craske M.G.
        Effects of an expanding-spaced vs. massed exposure schedule on fear reduction and return of fear.
        Behav Res Ther. 1998; 36: 701-717
        • Santini E.
        • Muller R.U.
        • Quirk G.J.
        • et al.
        Consolidation of extinction learning involves transfer from NMDA-independent to NMDA-dependent memory.
        J Neurosci. 2001; 21: 9009-9017
        • Smith S.M.
        Remembering in and out of context.
        J Exper Psychol Hum Learn Mem. 1979; 5: 460-471
        • Smith S.M.
        Environmental context-dependent memory.
        in: Davies G.M. Thomson D.M. Memory in Context Context in Memory. John Wiley and Sons, New York1988: 13-34
        • Spear N.E.
        The Processing of Memories. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ1978
        • Swartzentruber D.
        • Bouton M.E.
        Context sensitivity of conditioned suppression following preexposure to the conditioned stimulus.
        Anim Learn Behav. 1992; 20: 97-103
        • Tamai N.
        • Nakajima S.
        Renewal of formerly conditioned fear in rats after extensive extinction training.
        Int J Comp Psychol. 2000; 13: 137-147
        • Tsao J.C.I.
        • Craske M.G.
        Timing of treatment and return of fear.
        Behav Ther. 2000; 31: 479-497
        • Wagner A.R.
        SOP.
        in: Spear N.E. Miller R.R. Information Processing in Animals Memory Mechanisms. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ1981: 5-47
        • Walker D.L.
        • Davis M.
        The role of amygdala glutamate receptors in fear learning fear-potentiated startle and extinction.
        Pharmacol Biochem Behav. 2002; 71: 379-392
        • Walker D.L.
        • Ressler K.J.
        • Lu K.T.
        • Davis M.
        • et al.
        Facilitation of conditioned fear extinction by systemic administration of intra-amygdala infusions of D-cycloserine as assessed with fear-potentiated startle in rats.
        J Neurosci. 2002; 15: 2343-2351
        • Westbrook R.F.
        • Iordanova M.
        • Harris J.A.
        • McNally G.
        • Richardson R.
        • et al.
        Reinstatement of fear to an extinguished conditioned stimulus.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 2002; 28: 97-110
        • Westbrook R.F.
        • Jones M.L.
        • Bailey G.K.
        • Harris J.A.
        • et al.
        Contextual control over conditioned responding in a latent inhibition paradigm.
        J Exper Psychol Anim Behav Processes. 2000; 26: 157-173
        • Wolpe J.
        Psychotherapy by Reciprocal Inhibition. Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA1958