Biological Psychiatry
Volume 51, Issue 8 , Pages 659-667 , 15 April 2002

Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation versus electroconvulsive therapy for major depression: preliminary results of a randomized trial

  • Philip G Janicak

      Affiliations

    • Corresponding Author InformationAddress reprint requests to Philip G. Janicak, M.D., University of Illinois at Chicago, Department of Psychiatry, 1601 W. Taylor Street, Chicago IL 60612 USA
    • Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
    • ,
  • Sheila M Dowd

      Affiliations

    • Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
    • ,
  • Brian Martis

      Affiliations

    • Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
    • ,
  • Danesh Alam

      Affiliations

    • Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
    • ,
  • Dennis Beedle

      Affiliations

    • Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
    • ,
  • Jack Krasuski

      Affiliations

    • Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
    • ,
  • Mary Jane Strong

      Affiliations

    • Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
    • ,
  • Rajiv Sharma

      Affiliations

    • Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
    • ,
  • Cherise Rosen

      Affiliations

    • Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
    • ,
  • Marlos Viana

      Affiliations

    • Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA

Received 30 July 2001 ,Revised 12 November 2001 ,Accepted 21 November 2001.

References 

  1. Altman EG, Hedeker DR, Janicak PG, Peterson JL, Davis JM. The Clinician Administered Rating Scale (Development reliability and validation). Biol Psychiatry. 1994;36:124–134
  2. American Psychiatric Association . Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 4th edition. Washington, D.C: American Psychiatric Press; 1994;
  3. American Psychiatric Association . The Practice of Electroconvulsive Therapy. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press; 1990;
  4. Avery D. Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of medication-resistant depression (Preliminary data). J Nerv Ment Dis. 1999;187:114–117
  5. Barker AT, Freeston IL, Jalinous R, Jarratt JA. Magnetic stimulation of the human brain and peripheral nervous system (An introduction and the results of an initial clinical evaluation). Neurosurgery. 1987;20:100–109
  6. Beedle D, Krasuski J, Janicak PG. Advances in somatic therapies (Electroconvulsive therapy, repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation, and bright light therapy). In:  Janicak PG,  Davis JM,  Preskorn SH,  Ayd FJ editor. Principles and Practice of Psychopharmacology Update. Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkins; 1998;p. 1–17
  7. Berman RM, Narasimhan M, Sanacora G, Miano AP, Hoffman RE, Hu XS, et al. A randomized clinical trial of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of major depression. Biol Psychiatry. 2000;47:332–337
  8. Epstein C, Figiel G, McDonald W, Amazon-Leece Figiel L. Rapid rate transcranial magnetic stimulation in young and middle aged refractory depressed patients. Psychiatr Ann. 1998;28:36–39
  9. Figiel G, Epstein C, McDonald W, Amazon-Leece J, Figiel L, Saldivia A, et al. The use of rapid-rate transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) in refractory depressed patients. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci. 1998;10:20–25
  10. Fink M. Prejudice against ECT (Competition with psychological philosophies as a contribution to its stigma). Convuls Ther. 1997;13:253–265
  11. Gates JR, Dhuna A, Pascual-Leone A. Lack of pathologic changes in human temporal lobes after transcranial magnetic stimulation. Epilepsia. 1992;33:504–508
  12. George MS, Nahas Z, Molloy M, Speer A, Oliver NC, Li K, et al.  A controlled trial of daily left prefrontal cortex TMS for treating depression. Biol Psychiatry. 2000;48:962–970
  13. George MS, Nahas Z, Speer A, Avery D, Molloy M, Risch SC, et al.  How does TMS improve depression? Current hints about the role of intensity, frequency, location and dose. Biol Psychiatry. 1998;43(suppl):76
  14. George MS, Speer A, Molloy M, Nahas Z, Teneback CC, Risch SC, et al.  Low frequency daily left prefrontal rTMS improves mood in bipolar depression (A placebo-controlled case report). Hum Psychopharmacol. 1998;13:271–275
  15. George MS, Wassermann E, Kimbrell T, Little JT, Williams WE, Danielson AL, et al.  Mood improvement following daily left temporal repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in patients with depression (Placebo-controlled cross over trial). Am J Psychiatry. 1997;154:1752–1756
  16. Greer RA. Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of the L-DLPC in depressed patients. New Research Abstracts of the American Psychiatric Association Annual Meeting. 1998; Toronto, Canada. NR:301–149
  17. Grunhaus L, Dannon PN, Schreiber S, Dolberg OH, Amiaz R, Ziv R, et al. Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation is as effective as electroconvulsive therapy in the treatment of nondelusional major depressive disorder (An open study). Biol Psychiatry. 2000;47:314–324
  18. Gug W. Assessment Manual for Psychopharmacology Revised. Rockville, MD: U.S. Department of Health Education and Welfare, Public Health Service, Alcohol, Drug Abuse and Mental Health Administration; 1976; NIMH, 218–222
  19. Hallet M, Cohen LG. Human Motor Control Section, National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke, Bethesda, MD. JAMA. 1989;262:538–541
  20. Hamilton M. A rating scale for depression. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1960;23:56–62
  21. Hoflich G, Kasper S, Ruhrmann S, Moller H. Application of transcranial magnetic stimulation in treatment of drug resistant major depression (A report of two cases). Hum Psychopharmacol. 1993;8:361–365
  22. Hufnagel A, Claus D, Brunhoelzl C, Sudhop T. Short-term memory (No evidence of effect of rapid-repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in healthy individuals). J Neurol. 1993;240:373–376
  23. Janicak PG, Davis JM, Gibbons RD, Erickson S, Chang S, Gallagher P. Efficacy of electroconvulsive therapy (A meta-analysis). Am J Psychiatry. 1985;142:297–302
  24. Janicak PG, Davis JM, Preskorn SH, Ayd FA. Treatment with electroconvulsive therapy and other somatic therapies. Principles and Practice of Psychopharmacotherapy. 3rd ed.. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott-Williams & Wilkins; 2001; 327–368
  25. Janicak PG, Easton MS, Comaty JE, Dowd S, Davis JM. Efficacy of ECT in psychotic and nonpsychotic depression. Convuls Ther. 1989;5:314–320
  26. Janicak PG, Martis B. Strategies for treatment-resistant depression. Clin Cornerstone. 1999;1:58–71
  27. Janicak PG, Martis B, Krasuski JK, Beedle DB, Sharma RP. RTMS vs. ECT for major depressive episode. New Research Abstracts of the American Psychiatric Association. 2000; Annual Meeting Chicago NR # 546, 205
  28. Janicak PG, Sharma RP, Israni T, Dowd S, Altman E, Davis JM. Effects of unilateral-nondominant vs. bilateral ECT on memory and depression (A preliminary report). Psychopharmacol Bull. 1991;27:353–357
  29. Keck ME, Welt T, Post A, Muller MB, Toschi N, Wigger A, et al.  Neuroendocrine and behavioral effects of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in a psychopathological animal model are suggestive of antidepressant-like effects. Neuropsychopharmacology. 2001;24:337–349
  30. Kimbrell TA, Little JT, Dunn RT, Frye MT, Greenberg DD, Wassermann EM, et al.  Frequency dependence of antidepressant response to left prefrontal repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) as a function of baseline cerebral glucose metabolism. Biol Psychiatry. 1999;46:1603–1613
  31. Klein E, Kreinin IY, Chistyakov A, et al.  Therapeutic efficacy of right prefrontal slow repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in major depression (A double-blind controlled study). Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1999;56:315–320
  32. Kozel FA, Nahas Z, de Brux C, Molloy M, Lorberbaum JP, Bohning D, et al.  How coil-cortex distance relates to age, motor threshold, and antidepressant response to repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci. 2000;13:376–384
  33. Krystal AD, West M, Prado R, Greenside H, Zoldi S, Weiner D. EEG effects of ECT (Implications for rTMS). Depress Anxiety. 2000;12:157–165
  34. Levy N, Janicak PG, Martis B, et al.  Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) after ECT (A case report). Psychline. 2000;3:31–33
  35. Lisanby SH, Datto CJ, Szuba MP. ECT and rTMS (Past, present, and future). Depress Anxiety. 2000;12:115–117
  36. Lisanby SH, Gutman D, Luber B, Schroeder C, Sackeim HA. Sham TMS (Intracerebral measurement of the induced electrical field and the induction of motor-evoked potentials). Biol Psychiatry. 2001;49:460–463
  37. Lisanby SH, Luber B, Sackeim HA, Finck AD, Schroeder C. Deliberate seizure induction with repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in nonhuman primates. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2001;58:199–200
  38. Lisanby SH, Maddox JH, Prudic J, Devanand DP, Sackeim HA. The effects of electroconvulsive therapy on memory of autobiographical and public events. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2000;57:581–590
  39. Lisanby SH, Pascual-Leone A, Sampson SM, Boylan LS, Burt T, Sackeim HA. Augmentation of sertraline antidepressant treatment with transcranial magnetic stimulation. Biol Psychiatry. 2001;49:81S
  40. Lisanby SH, Schlaepfer TE, Fisch HU, Sackeim HA. Magnetic seizure therapy of major depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2001;58:303–305
  41. Little JT, Kimbrell TA, Wassermann EM, Grafman T, Figueras S, Dunn RT, et al.  Cognitive effects of 1 and 20 hertz repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in depression (Preliminary report). Neuropsychol Behav Neurol. 2000;13:119–124
  42. Loo CK, Mitchell PB, Sachdev PS, McDarmont BN, Parker G, Gandevia SC. Double-blind controlled investigation of transcranial magnetic stimulation in major depression. Am J Psychiatry. 1999;156:946–948
  43. Loo CK, Taylor JL, Gandevia SC, McDarmont BN, Mitchell PB, Sachdev PS. Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) in controlled treatment studies (Are some “sham” forms active?). Biol Psychiatry. 2000;47:325–331
  44. Martis B, Carson V, Sharma RP, Martin E, Janicak PG, Verma M, et al. Cognitive effects of rTMS in depressed patients. Psychiatric Association Annual Meeting Chicago. 2000; NR #81:77
  45. Martis B, Janicak PG. Transcranial magnetic stimulation and psychopharmacotherapy for major depression (Therapeutic possibilities). Int Drug Therapy Newsletter. 2000;35:1–11
  46. Nahas Z, DeBrux C, Chandler V, Lorberbaum JP, Speer AM, Molloy MA, et al.  Lack of significant changes on magnetic resonance scans before and after 2 weeks of daily left prefrontal repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation for depression. J ECT. 2000;16:380–390
  47. Nahas Z, Speer A, Molloy LI, Arana G, Risch S, George M. Frequency and intensity in the antidepressant effect of left prefrontal rTMS. Biol Psychiatry. 1998;43:94S
  48. Ornah T, Schreiber Grunhaus L. Transcranial magnetic stimulation-induced switch into mania (A report of two cases). Biol Psychiatry. 2001;49:468–470
  49. Overall JE, Gorham DR. The brief psychiatric rating scale. Psychol Reports. 1962;10:799–812
  50. Padberg F, Haag C, Zwanger P, Thoma H, Kathmann H, Haag C, et al.  Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) in pharmacotherapy-refractory major depression (Comparative study of fast, slow and sham rTMS). Psychiatry Res. 1999;88:163–171
  51. Pascual-Leone A, Rubio B, Pallardo F, Catala M. Rapid-rate transcranial magnetic stimulation of left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in drug resistant depression. Lancet. 1996;348:233–237
  52. Pridmore S. Substitution of rapid transcranial magnetic stimulation treatments for electroconvulsive therapy treatments in a course of electroconvulsive therapy. Depress Anxiety. 2000;12:118–123
  53. Pridmore S, Bruno R, Turnier-Shea Y, Reid P, Rybak M. Comparison of unlimited numbers of rTMS and ECT treatment sessions in major depression episode. Int J Neuropsychopharmacol. 2000;3:129–134
  54. Rush AJ, George MS, Sackeim HA, Marangell LB, Husain MM, Giller C, et al.  Vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) for treatment-resistant depressions (A multicenter study). Biol Psychiatry. 2000;47:276–286
  55. Sackeim HA. Repetitive TMS (What are the next steps?). Biol Psychiatry. 2000;48:959–961
  56. Sackeim HA, Prudic J, Devanand DP, Nobler MS, Lisanby SH, Peyser S, et al.  A prospective, randomized, double-blind comparison of bilateral and right unilateral electroconvulsive therapy at different stimulus intensities. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2000;57:425–434
  57. Sturm R, Wells KB. How can care for depression become more cost-effective?. JAMA. 1995;273:51–58
  58. Szuba MP, O’Reardon JP, Evans DL. Physiological effects of electroconvulsive therapy and transcranial magnetic stimulation in major depression. Depress Anxiety. 2000;12:170–177
  59. Terman JS, Terman M, Lo ES, Cooper TB. Circadian time of morning light administration and therapeutic response in winter depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2001;48:60–75
  60. Thase ME. How should efficacy be evaluated in randomized clinical trials of treatments for depression?. J Clin Psychiatry. 1999;60:23–32
  61. Wassermann EM. Risk and safety of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (Report and suggested guidelines from the International Workshop on the Safety of Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation, 1996). Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol. 1998;108:1–16
  62. Wassermann EM, Wang B, Zeffiro TA, et al.  Locating the motor cortex on the MRI with transcranial magnetic stimulation and PET. Neuroimage. 1996;3:1–9
  63. World Health Organization . Fact Sheet N 130. Mental Health, (1996, August).. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization, Health Communications and Public Relations; 1996; Available at http///C/TEMP/fact130.html. Accessed November 11, 2000
  64. Young RC, Biggs JT, Ziegler VE, Meyer DA. A rating scale for mania (Reliability, validity and sensitivity). Br J Psychiatry. 1978;133:429–435

PII: S0006-3223(01)01354-3

Biological Psychiatry
Volume 51, Issue 8 , Pages 659-667 , 15 April 2002

Article Tools

* Image Usage & Resolution